Review: Happy in Vain, The Lion & Unicorn Theatre

Worthy ambitions and a hard-working cast fail to salvage enough enlightenment or empathy from this poorly structured script and messy productionRating
OK
It’s hard to believe that 40 years have passed since the UK government’s first AIDS awareness campaign. Much has changed: antiretroviral drugs allow people to lead long, healthy lives, while PrEP (pre-exposure prophylaxis) and PEP (post-exposure prophylaxis), can prevent infection before and after potential exposure.
Rupert Shirley‘s Happy in Vain seeks to contrast experiences of HIV in the mid-1980s and today, with the modern story exploring a trial of a six-monthly treatment injection. For him it has autobiographical roots as he was one of the first people to be administered this new treatment. It’s an interesting idea to layer personal insight with an imagined historical perspective but a surer hand is needed to structure these parallel stories: the play’s clumsy architecture constantly undermines its ambitions.
The play sometimes moves between conventional scenes and poetic audience-facing soliloquies, as well as rapidly switching simultaneous ensemble pieces. Scattered throughout are real radio and TV broadcasts. It’s as if Shirley is desperate to imbue meaning into his material, but it comes at a cost: it’s difficult to follow and emotional arcs are uncomfortably entangled.
In the present, Thomas (Roshaan Sharpe), supported by his friend Scarlett (Freya Woolf), faces diagnosis and treatment following a one-night stand. Medical reality is fudged to facilitate the needs of the narrative: Thomas visits a clinic apparently the day after potential exposure, without any discussion of PEP, which can prevent infection if taken promptly. It’s a conspicuous omission in a story that requires him to contract HIV.
The 1980s story is similarly flawed. Fred (Leo Sermulins), a working-class man supporting his family, seemingly contracts HIV through casual sex with another man. He then thinks he unknowingly transmits it to his ill mother through a blood transfusion, because apparently only his blood can be used. Again, this plot device is inadequately explained, while, strangely, the possibility that his girlfriend (who has been with him in almost every scene) might also have been exposed goes unexplored.
Compounding this is weak direction from Nina Fuentes. At times it’s difficult to sense a guiding hand at all. The Lion & Unicorn‘s limited stage access presents a genuine challenge, especially with two narratives. Here, a director’s finesse should make transitions feel seamless. Instead, actors repeatedly simply stomp on and off through the same doorway.
When characters from both eras occupy the stage a more deft approach is attempted, with pools of light shifting our attention rapidly between their conversations. But the changes come too quickly, and lighting cues fail to keep pace with the dialogue. Instead of an insightful counterpoint the result is an unappealing mash-up. Elsewhere, there is little sense of a director’s DNA: era signposting is weak, movement lacks depth, lighting lacks texture, and the minimal set asks a garden bench to stand in for everything.
The cast deserve plaudits for rescuing some emotional engagement from this. Sharpe is convincingly sassy yet insecure and Sermulins brings inner conflict to taciturn Fred, though both wrestled with some garbled diction at key moments. Woolf and Frances Eva, as Janine, do very well to make the most of characters drawn rather too broadly.
The ending brings the two protagonists together in what seems to be an imagined encounter across the intervening four decades. This attempt to reconcile the two narratives simply highlights the flaws in juxtaposing them in the first place.
There is much to admire in Happy in Vain, but considerable work is still needed to craft a play that does justice to the seriousness of the topic and the play’s laudable ambitions.
Written by Rupert Shirley
Directed by Nina Fuentes
Assistant Direction by Lara May
Dramaturgy by Luis Hopkins
Lighting Design by Eva Belgrave
Happy in Vain plays at the Lion and Unicorn Theatre until Saturday 21 November



