Review: Villain Era, Bread and Roses Theatre

In 2019, Jubilee’s YouTube channel produced a video loosely based on Netflix’s Mole titled Odd Man Out: Vegans versus Meat Eaters, which went viral, becoming a major internet hit. This video, in which she featured, changed writer and performer Star Stone‘s life.

Villain Era focuses on how the video and the subsequent internet reactions affected Stone, leading her to face harassment and online trolling like that of a real life I Hate Suzie.

Stone was given ‘the villain edit’, a term used to describe how reality TV shows and other forms of pop culture media edit footage to depict someone negatively, manipulating them into the role of a villain to attract more views and engagement.

It takes bravery to address something so personal and impactful, and Stone navigates these tumultuous waters with grace. The performance feels cathartic, yet it leaves the audience questioning what message Stone wants to convey. Is it an explanation of what truly happened, a defence of her actions, or a critique of those who crafted the video?

This mixed-media one-woman show features Stone portraying various characters and her inner thoughts. She transitions seamlessly from one persona to another, showcasing remarkable versatility in her performance. However, the portrayal of the inner workings of her mind sometimes feels fragmented and disjointed, veering into absurdity that can distract from the poignant reality of her story.

Stone establishes a strong connection with the audience, making the piece feel conversational – as if she’s your friend at the bar sharing an animated story after a few drinks. However, at times, the tone can come off as patronising, as she asks the audience if they understand certain words and then takes the time to explain them.

The staging, set, and costumes are minimal, featuring just two chairs and a projector. Director Ryan Cunningham effectively complements the projections and, in keeping with the minimalism, keeps the focus directly on Stone.

There are powerful moments when Stone reflects on the cruel nature of the internet, discussing how memes and negative comments can linger for years and how she had to transform herself and her life to get to where she is now. Her commentary about how women are often portrayed as villains while men are seen as strategic hits home and leaves a lasting impression. However, some American references fall flat with a British audience, and the script could benefit from further revisions to create a more cohesive narrative with a clear core message.

Villain Era is a solo show that explores the cruel nature of social media and fame. It features some strong moments, but it remains unclear what Stone is ultimately trying to communicate about the events that shaped her life.

Written by Star Stone
Directed by Ryan Cunningham
Co-produced by Christine Walters

Villian Era plays at Bread and Roses Theatre until Monday 9 June.